Costello's Pub Text Title
Costello's Pub Sword
Costello's Pub Sign Photo
"About the pub"

Costello’s Pub is a no-frills hideaway where the beer is beer and the whiskey is whiskey. Like everything good about the Midwest, it’s housed in an unfinished basement.

But yeah, no, yeah--it's as warm, welcoming, and busy as an above-ground Irish pub. Don't think "drywall." Think "dim light, exposed beams, well-worn bar top."

Our goal is to turn neighbors into friends over pitchers of cheap beer and Jameson shots lined up on pool tables.

Join us down--but not out--in the basement at Costello's Pub.

"Events at the pub"
the halloween party flyer graphic with info about the date and time of the event
Event poster for The Donerick Boys Malort Night on Tuesday, November 18th, 2025 at 8:00 PM, featuring hands pouring Malört liquor shots over a splash effect above a yellow-tinted house.
Stranger things invitation graphic
Costello's Pub Tap Handle Photo
"What's on tap?"A photo of the garage beer logo with text telling you that it's a 4% ABV light beer.
"Location"

ASK A PUNK

"Hours"

MONDAY - THURSDAY

Usually no, but maybe yes. idk..

FRIDAY - SUNDAY

If there’s an away crew game going on then yes, we are probably open. BUT also, maybe not...

Email Icon Button
Instagram Icon Button
stationary map image
Legal: Costello's Pub is not a real pub. We do not sell anything. Don't come after me, IRS. I just got bored and wanted to create a fake website.